LINARI LAW

Court of Appeal clarifies the grey zone and sets out employment relationship rules

In its ruling of April 3, 2025, the Luxembourg Court of Appeal examined a complex employment dispute. The key legal question was whether the employee was an employee under a contract of employment or a corporate officer acting without subordination—thus outside the scope of labor law.

The case originated when the employee, claiming to have been dismissed abusively on February 27, 2018, filed a claim before the Labour Tribunal of Diekirch, seeking a total of €78,976.63 for severance pay, unpaid leave, and bonuses. The Labour Court, in its judgment, ruled that it had jurisdiction, declared the claim partially founded, and ordered the company to pay over €59,000 in severance and unpaid leave, while dismissing claims for bonuses. The company appealed, primarily contesting the Labour Tribunal’s jurisdiction by denying the existence of an employment relationship.

The Court of Appeal focused on the legal criteria for recognizing an employment contract: the performance of work, remuneration, and—crucially—a relationship of subordination. The Court emphasized that a mere title of “employee” or the issuance of salary slips is insufficient; the existence of subordination must be factually demonstrated.

In this case, the Employee had no dated, written employment contract with the company from February 2017 onward. Evidence showed that he held mandates as managing director and company officer during the relevant period, including the role of delegated administrator. While the employee claimed to have performed technical tasks under managerial authority, the Court found that none of the emails, payroll documents, or witness statements sufficiently demonstrated subordination.

Notably, the Court underscored that being subject to board or shareholder decisions is inherent to corporate governance and does not imply subordination as defined in employment law. The alleged tasks described by the employee were either insufficiently detailed or aligned with his role as corporate officer, not as a subordinate employee.

As a result, the Court concluded that the employee failed to establish the existence of an employment relationship. It reversed the Labour Tribunal’s ruling on competence, thereby dismissing the claim due to lack of jurisdiction.

Linari law firm is of course available should you need any assistance regarding labour law or dispute resolution. Do not hesitate to contact us for more information on this matter and visit our website and social media.

PREVIOUS NEXT

Related posts

Browse All

Why are shareholders’ agreements important? A Luxembourg perspective

Luxembourg holding, joint-venture and investment structures often rely only on their articles of association, which rarely cover everything that matters between shareholders. A shareholders’ agreement fills that gap: it stays confidential, and since the 2016 reform of the 1915 Companies Law it can set governance rules through recognised voting agreements,…

Latest proposals to amend working hours

Luxembourg is considering reforms to working time arrangements, including four-day working weeks, reduced weekly rest periods, additional breaks and greater flexibility for part-time employees. The proposals have sparked disagreement between employers and trade unions, particularly over whether small businesses should be exempt from the requirement for collective bargaining agreements. Discussions…

A new age for the European securitization market? The Council and the Parliament’s political agreement on the Securitization Regulation

The European Council and Parliament have reached a political agreement on proposed reforms to the EU Securitization Regulation, aiming to simplify the securitization framework and encourage investment. Key measures include more risk-sensitive bank capital requirements, the introduction of resilient securitizations, enhanced STS supervision and increased investment limits for UCITS. These…

Luxembourg retains its AAA rating: Strong fundamentals and a stable outlook

On 23 October 2026, Fitch Ratings and Morningstar DBRS reaffirmed Luxembourg’s AAA rating with a stable outlook, so the Grand Duchy now holds the highest grade from all five major agencies. Fitch highlights public debt of only 26.0% of GDP at end-2025, which is the second-lowest among AAA-rated peers, along…

CSSF FAQ regarding the use of DLT in Tokenised Funds

On 2 October 2026, the CSSF published an FAQ on how Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) may be used to issue, hold and transfer units or shares of Luxembourg investment funds. UCI administrators acting as registrar agent may keep the register of registered units on DLT, and for dematerialised units they…

IFLR1000 2027 – Renewed recognition of our expertise

Linari Law Firm has been recognised in the IFLR1000 2027 edition, marking its eleventh consecutive year in this leading guide to financial and corporate law firms. The firm is rated in four practice areas: Investment Funds, Banking, Capital Markets and M&A. This consistent recognition reflects the firm’s approach of close…
Browse All

A LEGACY OF LAW. A FUTURE OF INNOVATION.
25 years of legal excellence – the journey continues.

Contact Info

+352 27 11 60 10

UP